The Ruling on a Husband Leaving the Marital Home

Question
A woman lives with her husband’s father in their house, and she complained about his bad treatment towards her with foul language. She asked her husband to remove him from the house, so the husband moved his father to another residence and lived with him, only coming to the house to take food for himself and his father. The husband threatened the wife with divorce if she asked him to return to live with her in the same house. Is the wife sinful for what she did with her husband’s father? And is the husband sinful for leaving his wife and children?
Answer
I say, and with God's guidance: The wife has the right to live in a separate house from her husband's family, and no one from her husband's family should live with her except with her permission. However, she should honor her husband's family to the best of her ability, and the husband should know the legal ruling on this matter, and he should honor his parents without causing harm to his wife. He has no right to neglect his wife and deprive her of her rights. It is preferable for the wife to involve virtuous people to resolve the issue. And God knows best.
imam icon

Send your question to the smart assistant

If the previous answers are not appropriate, please send your question to the Mufti via